Welcome, Guest. Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length

Adrian Flux

Author Topic: 165bhp from a remap, should I expect more!?  (Read 1325 times)

FWD_Boy

  • S2000 Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 2044
  • Gumball Racing
165bhp from a remap, should I expect more!?
« on: January 27, 2012, 07:06:57 AM »
Ok so some of you might have seen my recent thread about 'Forge Actuators' (well its arrvided and looks very nice) and some of you might remember that do to my Forge BOV and my personal feelinhs of tuning boxes (nothing against them and Ive seen the figures to back TMCs boxes up) I just feel for me Id rather have a propper map.

Anyway... Ive seen 3cars with maps, two backed up by rolling road figures and one on the road that seemed to be as quick as the figure suggested. The real question is...

On a standard NP car which I accept makes 150bhp (as thats what mine made on a dyno) should I happy with a figure of 165bhp?

Now on the face of it from 150bhp to 165bhp that seems a good solid 15bhp gain, but if I was sporting a SS map 5bhp would be pony and also the two cars Ive seen backed up by RR graph only made 170bhp with full turbo back exhaust And induction kits so again looking at the face of it the sport cat, full exhaust and induction kit Only gave an extra 5bhp which really really really would dissapoint me, but having said that as the RR layout that them figures where taken on wasnt the greatest but then again mine was done on the same rollers.

Also to further mix things up Ive read on here a member who had their car mapped by Angel tunging I think and with just a Akprovik (spelling) claimed an unbeliveable 190bhp! I struggle to belive somebody could get that from a map and dual pressure back box, when other compaines are like nearly 25bhp short on their maps.

Confused.com I am :(

Just for some background info the:
2 cars had Forge induction kit, Milltek turbo back exhaust and where mapped by AmD
1 car was standard and mapped by Sanspeed
At present mine is sporting BMC panel filter, G-Tech turbo back 3" exhaust and the Forge actuator thats waiting to be fitted when the cars mapped

If anyone has got remapped ecu's Id be very interested to hear from you. Also Id love Daron to remap my car but its just the whole distance thing, if I cant really get the answers I want I might just have to bite the bullet and go see the man in the know lol
FWD_Boy - AKA 'Chris' A500 135bhp NP
G-Tech 200cell Sport cat, 3" centre section, Back box with Black tailpipes
Forge Dump valve, Silcone Induction hose
GTTuning Induction kit, Battery & Header tank covers

biancodiablo

  • Assetto Corse Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 355
Re: 165bhp from a remap, should I expect more!?
« Reply #1 on: January 27, 2012, 07:28:44 AM »
ive got sanspeed s/1 remap , standard esseesse, monza......... 171bhp on dyno. esseesse only takes it from 135 to 160bhp, remap s/1 will get another 10 or so , but torque figure is better and holds on longer, peak power is at 5500rpm, drops off after that............. but theres so much more that can be done ! only problem with mine is that at 3-4000rpm there seems to be a drop in power before resuming boosting, possibly an actuator / spring or solenoid fault ( as S J H reported with her car ) , getting it looked at soon tho, hope its only a minor blip !

sandys

  • S2000 Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 832
Re: 165bhp from a remap, should I expect more!?
« Reply #2 on: January 27, 2012, 09:24:33 AM »
On a standard NP car which I accept makes 150bhp (as thats what mine made on a dyno) should I happy with a figure of 165bhp?

Yes you should be happy, a standard NP is 135, anything over is a bonus, 190 on that small IHI turbo sounds optimistic to me (695 gets that with better setup), some cars may put out 170, your car on a different day with different temps, fuel quality could put out the same.

Does it feel good, can you feel an improvement, if so drive and be happy, don't quibble over 5bhp, I've seen that sort of variance on back to back runs with my car.

If your remapper claimed they can get your 200 or something then you might have cause to complain but a few bhp out over the normal sort of figures for that engine.  ::)
« Last Edit: January 27, 2012, 09:29:23 AM by sandys »

K77NAN

  • Assetto Corse Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 382
  • must.......go......faster
Re: 165bhp from a remap, should I expect more!?
« Reply #3 on: January 27, 2012, 10:20:28 AM »
What you need to remember here is, the headline figures only tell half the story. Let me tell you about my old Focus ST....

At first, when the car was basially standard, it was treated to a Superchips Bluefin...according to superchips that would give me around 255bhp (225 standard) and the car was certainly quicker. Over the next few months I added a full exhaust with decat, large intercooler, and closed induction kit. At this point the car was perfect for the Graham Goode Racing superchips map, which was specifically designed with those mods in mind, Again, there was a noticable improvement in performance 8)

Fast forward around 6 months, and there was a new kid on the scene, in the form of a company called Dreamscience...they claimed to have full access to the ECU and could change every setting, where the current tuners could only access basic functions...well didn't that sound like a load of bull....

As I was quite involved with the ST scene at the time, I was invited to their HQ in Hull to have the car reflashed with their new generic map for standard cars, for which they were claiming 271bhp. I was pretty sceptical it's fair to say, but when I took their demo car out, which was standard other than the map, it felt about as quick as mine, although it pulled better from low revs! I was pretty amazed, but not as much when they flashed the map onto my car. It simply blew the map I was running away, despite just being a generic map for standard cars! It actually used less boost, but kicked in lower and held longer. The peak torque was around 2.5k revs and held, so the car just pulled like a train! When they started to produce maps for modifed cars, it got better and better. Performance Ford tested my car at Bruntingthorpe and it recorded 0-60 in 5.7 seconds (6.7 std) and 157mph (150 std). On the rolling road, it made 291bhp an 361 lb/ft torque....a little disappointing, but we discovered it was a bit broken on the day and wasn't hitting wide open throttle due to a faulty throttle potentiometer :whistle:

So for my money, ignore the headline figures...get a test drive where you can, and ask to see a rolling road graph. A nice flat torque curve and linear power line will be better than a peaky headline power figure any day of the week :thumb:
« Last Edit: January 27, 2012, 10:23:04 AM by K77NAN »
Done: White Esseesse wheels, TMC box of magic, Eibach springs, Red wing mirrors, Carbon Wrap Dash

Coming soon: A bigger house

elomerid500

  • Assetto Member
  • **
  • Posts: 79
Re: 165bhp from a remap, should I expect more!?
« Reply #4 on: January 27, 2012, 10:34:36 AM »
No you shouldn't be happy with that, but then again depends how much you're paying for it. If its within the £300-400 price bracket then 165 sounds just about right for that sort of money.

Not all re-maps were created equal; I think people focus on the bhp figure way too much, instead of looking at torque. Can you test drive an in-house car thats got the map you want? If not then whats the point of it if  how you're not going to be happy with the remap?

Two weeks ago I visited a place that does remaps and test drove their vehicle and I was amazed at  how quick the thing was.

I had a long chat with the owner and he told me several things:
 
- a basic remap will get you to around 160-165bhp
- with a remap only, and an airfilter, you can get 180bhp max.
- with a remap, air filter and custom exhaust the most you can get out of the engine is around 190 bhp.
- there is almost no chance of a service wiping a remap; he's been doing them for years and years and has never had that happen. He also said he'd be happy to replace it for free if it did get erased.

So anyways, guess whos going back there next week to get up to 190? ;)

And I know lots of people are going to start going on about how 'no way is it 190' and 'you won't be able to re-sell your remap when you sell the car'.

Well, the guys got his own RR (I know youre gonna say its been set-up wrong blah blah), and he's been doing this for over 20 years, so I think by now people would have realised if he was ripping them off. Ive also seen the before and after printouts for bhp and torque :)

And I love my car, and tbh if you're already thinking of selling it in the future, then why bother tuning it at all? How can you expect to get good results if your main concern is how much of the money will be recoverable when you sell up?

Just my thoughts :P







corsa

  • S2000 Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1318
Re: 165bhp from a remap, should I expect more!?
« Reply #5 on: January 27, 2012, 11:53:48 AM »

I had a long chat with the owner and he told me several things:
 
- a basic remap will get you to around 160-165bhp
- with a remap only, and an airfilter, you can get 180bhp max.
- with a remap, air filter and custom exhaust the most you can get out of the engine is around 190 bhp.
- there is almost no chance of a service wiping a remap; he's been doing them for years and years and has never had that happen. He also said he'd be happy to replace it for free if it did get erased.


If I may ask, who is that company that you are talking to?

The remap only figure sounds about right to me...
An airfilter on a further unmodified car (so remap + airfilter/induction) as the A500, will never bring additional 15bhp though, hence why the expression probably is "max 180".
If the airfilter brings any measurable advantage it will be in the lower single digit figures, not only my experience on a variety of cars, but also the general experience here with different tuners.

I doubt that 190bhp will be achievable without further hardware modifications.

If you proof me wrong the better it is though ;D

To compete in a contest of speed.
Never try to teach a pig to sing.

elomerid500

  • Assetto Member
  • **
  • Posts: 79
Re: 165bhp from a remap, should I expect more!?
« Reply #6 on: January 27, 2012, 01:17:54 PM »

I had a long chat with the owner and he told me several things:
 
- a basic remap will get you to around 160-165bhp
- with a remap only, and an airfilter, you can get 180bhp max.
- with a remap, air filter and custom exhaust the most you can get out of the engine is around 190 bhp.
- there is almost no chance of a service wiping a remap; he's been doing them for years and years and has never had that happen. He also said he'd be happy to replace it for free if it did get erased.


If I may ask, who is that company that you are talking to?

The remap only figure sounds about right to me...
An airfilter on a further unmodified car (so remap + airfilter/induction) as the A500, will never bring additional 15bhp though, hence why the expression probably is "max 180".
If the airfilter brings any measurable advantage it will be in the lower single digit figures, not only my experience on a variety of cars, but also the general experience here with different tuners.

I doubt that 190bhp will be achievable without further hardware modifications.

If you proof me wrong the better it is though ;D



I cant say on here as it will be censored. Ill make a post when I've had mine done (next week) so you can have a look.

No, it is 180bhp, I have seen the graphs for it. I never said the airfilter would give massive gains, its all to do with the map - its not the same map as the 165 map.

turbolad

  • Assetto Member
  • **
  • Posts: 61
Re: 165bhp from a remap, should I expect more!?
« Reply #7 on: January 27, 2012, 02:07:57 PM »
Well here is my thoughts based on previous cars I've modded.

Standard cat-back abarth exhaust system, the bore is plenty for 200bhp let alone 135 or 160 bhp IMO. There is no resistance in this exhaust system it only has one box and two exits and is very short. The only bit worth changing is the turbo downpipe and cat to a 200 CPI sport cat with a more freeflowing bend. Putting a 3" drainpipe on a 1.4 turbo is way overkill and a waste of money. Although it's said turbos like less back pressure there is no benefit to doing it on this car with the standard turbo.

If you want 200 bhp from this car, you need the punto's bigger turbo and its injectors. Then a remap will yield much greater results and it will be worthwhile upgrading the intercooler.

I'm sure if someone got the prices from fiat, we could buy the turbo, injectors and manifold for a cheap price, then add a remap. job done.

In my Vauxhall days everyone was upgrading to VXR turbo's. A VXR turbo and manifold only cost me £445 brand new with fitting parts.

Oh yeah and induction filters, sorry waste of time - the GTT one looks OK but not worth the money at all.

« Last Edit: January 27, 2012, 02:10:24 PM by turbolad »

Griffs998

  • Esseesse Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 190
Re: 165bhp from a remap, should I expect more!?
« Reply #8 on: January 27, 2012, 02:10:11 PM »
first things first - the 190hp that was claimed after a simple re-map and backbox is garbage, im not saying to chap didnt see the figure of 190 appear after his dyno run but it wouldnt be repeated on many if any other dyno's. The set up he is running simply dosent make that power. A remaped or boxed ss makes around 170, its fairly safe to assume thats the limit for the turbo ON THE STANDARD ACTUATOR. Changing the actuator roland (whisper it from GTT) said that the standard actuator could only allow about 0.5 bar of boost at 5500rpm and his upgraded actuator was able to take the turbo to its safe maximum at that level which is about 1.1 bar. Thats a lot more boost so i think its fairly safe to assume that will be worth at least another 10bhp with your turbo back exhaust worth a few more after that.

Your should be looking at mid 180's at least with your setup- its not as simple as just adding 10 for this and 5 for that- how things work together is always hard to predict but assuming you sort the intake out aswell i would expect you to read anywhere from 180 - 200 depending on dyno - if you're not satisfied with any mappers near you id arrange to see daron or at least ask if you can meet him in his workshop up north to install the bits and map it for you - at least then with whatever figure you get you can be sure its pretty much the max you'll get out of whatever set up you're running

corsa

  • S2000 Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1318
Re: 165bhp from a remap, should I expect more!?
« Reply #9 on: January 27, 2012, 02:19:48 PM »
Good to see, that I am not the only one with some doubts...
I have modified quite a few of my own cars, and think I have some sort of experience in it :P

It's pretty much possible to remap the Abarth to 210 bhp with standard hardware, but I am not sure how long that would work :P

To compete in a contest of speed.
Never try to teach a pig to sing.

TMC-Motorsport

  • Guest
Re: 165bhp from a remap, should I expect more!?
« Reply #10 on: January 27, 2012, 02:28:34 PM »
Good to see, that I am not the only one with some doubts...
I have modified quite a few of my own cars, and think I have some sort of experience in it :P

It's pretty much possible to remap the Abarth to 210 bhp with standard hardware, but I am not sure how long that would work :P



I disagree, sorry, I don't think the standard turbo will ever break 200bhp no matter how you map it, I'd be happy for someone to prove me wrong.

corsa

  • S2000 Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1318
Re: 165bhp from a remap, should I expect more!?
« Reply #11 on: January 27, 2012, 02:30:26 PM »
Good to see, that I am not the only one with some doubts...
I have modified quite a few of my own cars, and think I have some sort of experience in it :P

It's pretty much possible to remap the Abarth to 210 bhp with standard hardware, but I am not sure how long that would work :P



I disagree, sorry, I don't think the standard turbo will ever break 200bhp no matter how you map it, I'd be happy for someone to prove me wrong.

Maybe my post was a bit wrong...
What I meant is that you can get the 200bhp, but that this will only work for about 400 yards ;)

I fully agree with you there Daron that some figures are not achievable with a certain configuration... :thumb:
To compete in a contest of speed.
Never try to teach a pig to sing.

TMC-Motorsport

  • Guest
Re: 165bhp from a remap, should I expect more!?
« Reply #12 on: January 27, 2012, 02:32:36 PM »
You need a bigger turbo to top 200 bhp, the IHI is tapped out around 180 ish.

Griffs998

  • Esseesse Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 190
Re: 165bhp from a remap, should I expect more!?
« Reply #13 on: January 27, 2012, 02:46:57 PM »
As daron says i dont think no matter how you map it you'll be able to get over 200 hp - the point isnt to deliver as much boost to the engine rather the most oxygen. Past a certain point the turbo will just be blowing very hot air which will actually decrease the amount of oxygen going to the engine and subsequently power. Corsa, get some pics of your hypermotard up -  ;D

Turbolad - The standard exhaust system is inefficient to say the least - the backbox can flow a reasonable amount but the standard cat and centre section if changed will show and improvement on a standard car let alone one that has been tuned and thus needs to void more gases. The centre section is narrow but is further crushed down just at the point after it connects to the cat where there is an oxygen sensor. So even though the rest of the pipe after that is wider (still narrow) backpressure has already been created by the crushed section at the front. The g-tech is 70mm which is 2.75 inches- slightly surplus to requirements but with a turbo wont matter as it simply wont increase power any further not reduce it 

Hozepipe

  • S2000 Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 2486
Re: 165bhp from a remap, should I expect more!?
« Reply #14 on: January 27, 2012, 02:52:36 PM »
The model of IHI turbo on the A500 is only spec'd to 180bhp (source John501). Why would you want to risk pushing it beyond its limits and compromise its integrity? Just do a DQ, I'm sure Daron can supply :)
Abu Dhabi Blue Abarth 695 Tributo Ferrari