Welcome, Guest. Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length


Author Topic: The A500 Steering in "Sport" mode  (Read 7368 times)

Offline Aviator

  • Assetto Member
  • **
  • Posts: 59
  • Carlo Rating: 0
  • If its good enough for Schumy!
    • Hampton Ct
Re: The A500 Steering in "Sport" mode
« Reply #15 on: October 06, 2012, 08:11:03 am »
Hey Scorpion,

Filled up at the Shell garage last night at Gatwick on my way hone from work and decided to commit a sin and have turned off the "stupid" switch! Car feels dreadfully restrained in one sense and freed in another...

During a significant turn the steering turns the A500 in quite sharply but doesn't try to self center itself, still feels a bit numb like a lot of cars but most importantly doesn't try to turn away from you. Having got used to the "stupid" mode it feels almost too light! But after my 30 mile drive home normal ish again.

During a turn I found small adjustments less frustrating and the sensation of having two thick rubber bands strapped to each side of the steering wheel trying to work against you removed!

Were all different and hopefully I'm just going to learn to live with the weird style. What's someone's problem ain't another's but I'm really keen on hearing others takes on this subject.

Everything else is so good (the engine torque!) I soon find myself just getting on with it. I'm doing a trackday at Silverstone on Monday (not taking the A500... As the group I'm with consists of a Mp4-12c, a GTR, Atom S and a 997 GT3 so it would be unfair to show all these guys up in my A500!! :thumb:

AbarthForum.co.uk

  • Advertisement
  • ***

    Offline Harley

    • Assetto Member
    • **
    • Posts: 90
    • Carlo Rating: 0
      • Melbourne, Australia
    Re: The A500 Steering in "Sport" mode
    « Reply #16 on: October 06, 2012, 12:05:10 pm »
    I drive my 500 around with sport mode off. Have done so daily now for a year since I got it.
    The reason for this is mainly the steering -  it feels much better that way. The lighter steering has more feedback and feels more suited to the cars weight, and you can feel where the car is pointed, don't have to guess.
    I'd rather make better use of the 'lesser' power and be able to feel it and use it properly, than have lots and not know where I'm going with it.

    Offline Aviator

    • Assetto Member
    • **
    • Posts: 59
    • Carlo Rating: 0
    • If its good enough for Schumy!
      • Hampton Ct
    Re: The A500 Steering in "Sport" mode
    « Reply #17 on: October 06, 2012, 05:56:38 pm »
    I'm with you on that Harley, it's not how fast your going that makes it fun it's how your doing it! Throttle response is pretty dodgy without! Arrggghh so frustrating, perfectly good car spoilt.

    Any indie specialists know how to free the power without the steering interference?

    Cheers,
     :thumb:

    Offline Scorpion

    • S2000 Member
    • *****
    • Posts: 580
    • Carlo Rating: 1
    • Size isn't everything! -well in cars it isn't!
      • Farringdon, near Exeter, DEVON
    Re: The A500 Steering in "Sport" mode
    « Reply #18 on: October 06, 2012, 06:10:16 pm »
    I'm with you on that Harley, it's not how fast your going that makes it fun it's how your doing it! Throttle response is pretty dodgy without! Arrggghh so frustrating, perfectly good car spoilt.

    Any indie specialists know how to free the power without the steering interference?

    Cheers,
     :thumb:

    Now there's a question ..... I think someone smart with a laptop can plug into the diagnostic thingy and do some magic?......
    Size isn't everything! -well in cars it isn't!

    Offline Aviator

    • Assetto Member
    • **
    • Posts: 59
    • Carlo Rating: 0
    • If its good enough for Schumy!
      • Hampton Ct
    Re: The A500 Steering in "Sport" mode
    « Reply #19 on: October 07, 2012, 12:05:22 am »
    I'm with you on that Harley, it's not how fast your going that makes it fun it's how your doing it! Throttle response is pretty dodgy without! Arrggghh so frustrating, perfectly good car spoilt.

    Any indie specialists know how to free the power without the steering interference?

    Cheers,
     :thumb:

    Now there's a question ..... I think someone smart with a laptop can plug into the diagnostic thingy and do some magic?......
    :thumb:

    Offline harrytguy

    • Esseesse Member
    • ***
    • Posts: 143
    • Carlo Rating: 0
    Re: The A500 Steering in "Sport" mode
    « Reply #20 on: October 07, 2012, 08:39:03 am »
    I used to think the same, until I changed the front tyres from the P Zeros to some Toyo Proxes... That made a HUGE and positive difference in the handling and the feel of it :thumb:

    Offline Aviator

    • Assetto Member
    • **
    • Posts: 59
    • Carlo Rating: 0
    • If its good enough for Schumy!
      • Hampton Ct
    Re: The A500 Steering in "Sport" mode
    « Reply #21 on: October 07, 2012, 11:01:21 pm »
    Now that's very interesting, thanks for that. That's exactly the sort of detail that could make a huge difference and make the most of what we've got and stop me trading the car in this Spring for a something else.

    What's your grip like on day to day? In particular wet/cold/icy days? Do you use your car every day? My cousin uses those on his Elise SC but that's a weekend toy!

     :thumb:

    Offline hot_fiat

    • Esseesse Member
    • ***
    • Posts: 213
    • Carlo Rating: 0
      • Houghton-le-Spring
    Re: The A500 Steering in "Sport" mode
    « Reply #22 on: October 08, 2012, 11:06:13 am »
    I've learned two valuable tyre lessons in the last few years:
      Cheap, junk tyres ruin vehicles
      Pirelli make junk tyres

    They make the most over-rated, poor-wearing, expensive, noisy, random-handling strips of black rubber.
    While initially handling beautifully, the grip falls off precipitously on some random Wednesday when you're just popping to the shops for a pint of milk.

    The KTM came with scorpion syncs which were great. Until I realized that I was spending more on tyres than fluids each year, the centre of the tread seemingly evaporating away in the bike shed, revealing a hidden layer of what could only be described as coal.

    The Cinq shipped with p700zs, which always made it feel dead, unless it was raining, in which case the car behaved as if possessed by the ghost of Huggy Bear's Cadillac, especially on motorways. But thanks to some careful negotiation on behalf of the mafia, they were the only people who made the obscure 165/55r13 size at the time so we were all stuck with them until the Seis, and bigger wheels came along.

    The wife-to-be's Seat has the zeros. They're so noisy that it sounds like the wheel bearings are filled with grit.

    My 16s are fitted with what are supposedly Pirelli's snow tyres (Not the sottozeros, which according to me bro are surprisingly awesome). They're ok, but me mum can still out-handle, out-climb and out-break it in her Michelin-equipped Panda.

    And don't even dream of putting them on a track, lest you want to be black-flagged for leaving FOD.

    Terrible terrible rubber.

    I don't like 'em. Can you tell? </rant>
    Andy
    Cinq 1242 16v, KTM 950 SM
    595 Comp

    Offline lloyd

    • S2000 Member
    • *****
    • Posts: 9336
    • Carlo Rating: 24
    Re: The A500 Steering in "Sport" mode
    « Reply #23 on: October 08, 2012, 01:38:25 pm »
    yet my Pirrellis are just fine, strange world :thumb:

    Offline harrytguy

    • Esseesse Member
    • ***
    • Posts: 143
    • Carlo Rating: 0
    Re: The A500 Steering in "Sport" mode
    « Reply #24 on: October 08, 2012, 03:20:34 pm »
    Now that's very interesting, thanks for that. That's exactly the sort of detail that could make a huge difference and make the most of what we've got and stop me trading the car in this Spring for a something else.

    What's your grip like on day to day? In particular wet/cold/icy days? Do you use your car every day? My cousin uses those on his Elise SC but that's a weekend toy!

     :thumb:

    Yep - I use my car most days..

    The Pirellis lasted 8000 miles / just over a year and I had got totally used to all of the handling 'quirks'... But when they ran out of tread I decided to go for something else and can honestly say it was like driving a different car!

    I've had the Toyos on for just under 2000 miles so haven't had them on any ice yet - but living in the North East we've had plenty of rain! The grip in the wet is better than the Pirellis by a loooong way.. There was always a little bit of panic that set in when cornering in the wet.. The car felt like it was sliding rather than turning! The Toyos have none of that though - they feel just as planted in the wet as they do in the dry.

    I also found that the car liked to find tracks in the road (it even did it with lane markings) which you had to fight to get out of.. Making for some interesting overtaking! I tried changing tyre pressures etc a few times, but nothing was any better.. Until I changed tyres and then this problem vanished!

    In my opinion changing the tyres has made a bigger difference than the TMC box did.

    (Having said all of that - I did love the car before I got new tyres... But I love it even more now! :thumb:)
    « Last Edit: October 08, 2012, 03:22:56 pm by harrytguy »

    Offline Aviator

    • Assetto Member
    • **
    • Posts: 59
    • Carlo Rating: 0
    • If its good enough for Schumy!
      • Hampton Ct
    Re: The A500 Steering in "Sport" mode
    « Reply #25 on: October 08, 2012, 11:54:54 pm »
    Harrytguy & Hotfiat,

    Thanks so much much for sharing that info. This thread now has some useful experiences/opinions/ideas.

    I'm 100% convinced to have a go at trying the toyo proxy as a replacement when the time comes. My P-Zero's grip well for now, but will watch there performance in the coming months. Difficult to tell with the rapidly changing temps/moisture and wear all at once! ::)

    I drove a Renaultsport Megane RS today at Silverstone in the wet. Low grip but great chassis and steering around the International shortened circuit, awesome fun. A lot of the cars at the circuit today as always were wearing Toyo's...

    I left my car in non-sport mode on the way back and ragged it!

     :thumb:

    « Last Edit: October 09, 2012, 12:01:51 am by Aviator »

    Offline Aviator

    • Assetto Member
    • **
    • Posts: 59
    • Carlo Rating: 0
    • If its good enough for Schumy!
      • Hampton Ct
    Re: The A500 Steering in "Sport" mode
    « Reply #26 on: October 08, 2012, 11:57:02 pm »
    Now that's very interesting, thanks for that. That's exactly the sort of detail that could make a huge difference and make the most of what we've got and stop me trading the car in this Spring for a something else.

    What's your grip like on day to day? In particular wet/cold/icy days? Do you use your car every day? My cousin uses those on his Elise SC but that's a weekend toy!

     :thumb:

    Yep - I use my car most days..

    The Pirellis lasted 8000 miles / just over a year and I had got totally used to all of the handling 'quirks'... But when they ran out of tread I decided to go for something else and can honestly say it was like driving a different car!

    I've had the Toyos on for just under 2000 miles so haven't had them on any ice yet - but living in the North East we've had plenty of rain! The grip in the wet is better than the Pirellis by a loooong way.. There was always a little bit of panic that set in when cornering in the wet.. The car felt like it was sliding rather than turning! The Toyos have none of that though - they feel just as planted in the wet as they do in the dry.

    I also found that the car liked to find tracks in the road (it even did it with lane markings) which you had to fight to get out of.. Making for some interesting overtaking! I tried changing tyre pressures etc a few times, but nothing was any better.. Until I changed tyres and then this problem vanished!

    In my opinion changing the tyres has made a bigger difference than the TMC box did.

    (Having said all of that - I did love the car before I got new tyres... But I love it even more now! :thumb:)

    Just re-read that..

    Toyo's going on next time for sure!

    Cheers,
    A

    Offline Wheels72

    • Esseesse Member
    • ***
    • Posts: 105
    • Carlo Rating: 0
      • Warwickshire
    Re: The A500 Steering in "Sport" mode
    « Reply #27 on: October 09, 2012, 08:51:58 am »
    I used to think the same, until I changed the front tyres from the P Zeros to some Toyo Proxes... That made a HUGE and positive difference in the handling and the feel of it :thumb:

    I'm glad that you found such an improvement with the Toyos, but surely the self centring pull is an electro-mechanical feature which will apply whatever the rubber (though I should add that I'm nooooo engineer.)
    I read a 3 car comparison review in September's Car magazine (at the dentist) yesterday, and they criticized the steering and the ride on the SS. The ride can be addressed with different dampers etc., but the steering in Sport seems to be something we just have to adapt to.
    I'd been permanently in Sport mode since having my car SS'd in May but I've found over the last couple of days that, for me, less is more as in Normal the steering is so much more natural, and I enjoy working the throttle as you need to in Normal.
    I appreciate that this is probably a minority position, but each to their own.
    Bossa White A500SS with Koni Smoothies.

    Offline Aviator

    • Assetto Member
    • **
    • Posts: 59
    • Carlo Rating: 0
    • If its good enough for Schumy!
      • Hampton Ct
    Re: The A500 Steering in "Sport" mode
    « Reply #28 on: October 09, 2012, 11:46:03 am »
    I used to think the same, until I changed the front tyres from the P Zeros to some Toyo Proxes... That made a HUGE and positive difference in the handling and the feel of it :thumb:

    I'm glad that you found such an improvement with the Toyos, but surely the self centring pull is an electro-mechanical feature which will apply whatever the rubber (though I should add that I'm nooooo engineer.)
    I read a 3 car comparison review in September's Car magazine (at the dentist) yesterday, and they criticized the steering and the ride on the SS. The ride can be addressed with different dampers etc., but the steering in Sport seems to be something we just have to adapt to.
    I'd been permanently in Sport mode since having my car SS'd in May but I've found over the last couple of days that, for me, less is more as in Normal the steering is so much more natural, and I enjoy working the throttle as you need to in Normal.
    I appreciate that this is probably a minority position, but each to their own.

    Wheels72,

    Your not at all, I feel exactly the same. Working the throttle, feeling the steering and simply enjoying driving is whats it's about for me.

    I'm defo going to make a call or two to see if would be possible to have the full range of throttle response all the time without the steering resistance.

    Thanks for your comment, your not alone!
     :wave:

    Offline hot_fiat

    • Esseesse Member
    • ***
    • Posts: 213
    • Carlo Rating: 0
      • Houghton-le-Spring
    Re: The A500 Steering in "Sport" mode
    « Reply #29 on: October 09, 2012, 03:25:18 pm »
    The lack of feel is the servo constantly providing damping torque to the steering column. An electronically damped feedback circuit will try to limit this effect. I can only imagine that this is worse in non-sport mode where it'll have to provide the greatest amount of torque. You can experience the effect of this by starting the car, engaging non-sport and moving the wheel back & forth with two fingers. You can feel the column buzzing slightly and the wheel moves in teeny-weeny judders, a bit like spinning a lego motor rotor in your fingers: theres a little bit of resistance & then it snaps to the next position. This isn't the motor itself (it spins too fast for you to feel it), but the ECU trying to decide what the heck you're doing and providing corrective torque in little tranches.

    I'd like a different option: the ability to turn the steering assistance off completely, or perhaps have it assist in different degrees depending on speed.

    Perhaps following this logic:

    Non-sport mode (ss) 160bhp, throttle as it is on sport now. full assistance <30mph then dropping away with speed.

    Sport mode 160bhp, throttle as on sport now, full assistance <5mph, no assistance <60mph then current sport mode assistance.

    Wonder what it's like with the fuse pulled?
    Andy
    Cinq 1242 16v, KTM 950 SM
    595 Comp